Thick cookie dough can be hard to scoop. Peanut butter, oatmeal, or gingerbread dough sticks to spoons and breaks cheap tools. But a strong cookie scoop makes it easy. Here include 5 best cookie scoop for thick dough.
We tested 8 scoops with heavy doughs. Below are the 5 best cookie scoop for thick dough that won’t bend, jam, or frustrate you.
Table of Contents
What Makes a Good Scoop for Thick Dough?
- Strong Material: Stainless steel lasts longer than plastic.
- Easy Release: A spring lever helps dough slide out fast.
- Comfy Grip: Soft handles save your hands during big batches.
- Dishwasher Safe: Easy cleanup is a must.
5 Best Cookie Scoops for Thick Dough
1. Vollrath Stainless Steel Scoop
Black stainless steel scoop with soft-grip handle. Holds 1.5 Tbsp dough. Dishwasher-safe.
Best For
- Small cookies (1.5-inch portions).
- Quick baking (speeds up dough shaping).
- Casual home bakers.
- Rock-hard dough (like gingerbread).
Why It Wins
✅ Soft grip for comfort.
✅ Spring release for easy dough drop.
✅ Uniform cookie sizes.
✅ Dishwasher-safe.
✅ Heavy-duty steel.
✅ No bending.
✅ Smooth spring.
Drawback
❌ Some report handles break or pinch hands.
❌ Mixed quality reviews (may not last long).
❌ Not ideal for thick/sticky dough.
2. OXO Good Grips Medium Cookie Scoop
Stainless steel scoop with soft grip. Holds 1.5 Tbsp dough. Dishwasher-safe.
Best For
- Uniform cookies (2.75-inch size).
- Sticky or tough dough.
- Big batches (comfortable grip).
- Everyday thick dough (peanut butter, oatmeal).
Why It Wins
✅ Soft, non-slip handle (no hand fatigue).
✅ Wiper ejects dough cleanly (no sticking).
✅ Works for soft and thick dough.
✅ Soft grip & Strong spring.
✅ Dishwasher-safe.
✅ Soft grip & Strong spring.
Drawback
❌ Fixed size (not for jumbo cookies).
❌ Struggles with extra sticky dough.
3. Winco Stainless Steel Disher
Stainless steel scoop. Holds 1/2 oz. Dishwasher-safe. Commercial-grade.
Best For
- Portioning soft foods (rice, mashed potatoes).
- Large batches (cookie dough, batters).
- Commercial kitchens or heavy home use.
- Big batches (bakeries or parties).
Why It Wins
✅ Commercial strength. Easy to clean.
✅ Durable 18/8 stainless steel (lasts for years).
✅ Whole-hand squeeze (prevents thumb fatigue).
✅ Quick-release blade (no sticky leftovers).
✅ Versatile (works for cooking and baking).
Drawback:
❌ No cushioned grip (plain handle).
❌ Heavy (not for small hands).
4. Norpro Cookie Scoop
Stainless steel scoop with soft grip. Holds 2 Tbsp. Hand-wash recommended.
Best For
- Uniform cookies or meatballs.
- Ice cream, pet food, meal prep.
- Home bakers needing versatility.
- Thick + sticky dough (like sugar cookies).
Why It Wins
✅ Non-stick coating. No sticking.
✅ Soft rubber grip (comfortable for big batches).
✅ Heavy-duty spring (releases dough cleanly).
✅ Multi-use (cooking, baking, pets).
✅ Affordable price.
Drawback
❌ Hand-wash only.
❌ Mixed durability (some report breakage).
❌ Hand-wash only (not dishwasher-safe).
❌ Not for ultra-thick dough.
5. KitchenAid Gourmet Cookie Dough Scoop
Black stainless steel scoop with soft-grip handle. Holds 1.5 Tbsp dough. Dishwasher-safe.
Best For
- Gifts or colorful kitchens.
- Small cookies (1.5-inch portions).
- Quick baking (speeds up dough shaping).
- Casual home bakers.
Why It Wins
✅ Soft grip for comfort.
✅ Spring release for easy dough drop.
✅ Pretty colors. Good for medium-thick dough.
✅ Uniform cookie sizes.
✅ Dishwasher-safe.
Drawback
❌ Spring jams sometimes.
❌ Some report handles break or pinch hands.
❌ Mixed quality reviews (may not last long).
❌ Not ideal for thick/sticky dough.
Quick Comparison
| Scoop | Price | Best For | Dishwasher-Safe? |
| Vollrath | $14.89 | Rock-hard dough | Yes |
| OXO | $16.92 | Everyday use | Yes |
| Winco | $13.64 | Big batches | Yes |
| Norpro | $16.66 | Sticky dough | No |
| KitchenAid | $13.67 | Gifts | Yes |
Tips for Scooping Thick Dough
- Spray the scoop: Light oil stops dough from sticking.
- Press hard: Push the scoop deep into the dough.
- Twist and lift: Makes clean, round balls.
Final Choice
Upgrade your baking today! Click the links to find best cookie scoop for thick dough on Amazon. No more fighting with dough – just perfect cookies every time.
- Strongest Pick: Vollrath
- Budget Pick: OXO Good Grips
- Easy Cleanup: Winco
Are you interested with sand treasure hunters? Top 10 Best Metal Detecting Sand Scoops For Treasure Hunters.
FAQ
Q: Can these scoops handle peanut butter dough?
A: Yes! Vollrath and OXO work best.
Q: How to clean stuck dough?
A: Soak the scoop in warm water for 5 minutes.
Q: What size scoop for big cookies?
A: Use a #20 (3 Tbsp) for bakery-sized cookies.
